OFFER
An offer endows the offeree with the capacity to accept, simultaneously imposing a potential obligation on the offeror. To qualify as an offer, the communication must engender a reasonable belief in the offeree that the offeror is prepared to forge a contract based on the essential terms proposed.
1.1 Expression of Willingness
For a communication to be recognised as an offer, it must manifest a willingness in the form of a promise, undertaking, or commitment to engage in a contract, distinguishing it from a mere invitation to initiate negotiations. It should reflect a clear intent to enter into a contractual agreement. Not every statement in the negotiation phases constitutes an offer.
For instance, if Clara says to David, “I intend to sell my laptop to you for £400,” this statement qualifies as a definitive offer.
1.2 SPECIFICITY AND EXACTITUDE OF TERMS
The terms of an offer must be articulated with specificity and exactitude. This means that the terms cannot be nebulous or partial.
The essential point is whether the key terms are detailed enough to render a contract enforceable if they were to be included. The particulars of the agreement, especially the subject matter, need to be distinctly specified, as enforceability hinges on a court's ability to determine the specifics of the promise.
For instance, if Emma tells Jack, “I agree to sell you this particular bicycle for £250,” it clearly and precisely outlines the intent, identifying both the item and its price. On the other hand, if Emma says to Jack, “I might sell a bicycle for something like £250,” it lacks clear commitment, specificity regarding which bicycle is being offered, and a fixed price.
1.3 OFFER NOTIFICATION TO THE OFFEREE
For an offeree to possess the capacity to accept, they must be aware of the offer's existence. Consequently, the offer must be effectively communicated to them. An offer can be directed towards a specific individual or group or be made universally, addressing the general public.
1.4 COMMUNICATIONS NOT CONSTITUTING AN OFFER
Responses to Requests for Information. Replying to a request for specific information only sometimes qualifies as an offer.
Consider a situation where a potential buyer emails a car dealer asking, “What is the best price you can offer for the 2020 Model X car?” The dealer responds, “The best price for the 2020 Model X is £15,000.” This response by the dealer does not amount to an offer. It merely provides information in response to the enquiry and does not represent a binding commitment to sell the car at that price.
Invitations to Treat
An invitation to treat is a preliminary step in contractual negotiations, distinct from an actual offer. It typically signifies an invitation for the other party to submit an offer.
In a scenario where Clara asks Emma if she would be interested in buying Clara’s bike for £300, Clara's query represents an invitation to treat. Emma can respond with an offer to buy the bike, which may lead to further negotiations or an acceptance.
Advertisements as Invitations to Treat
Typically, advertisements are treated as invitations to treat rather than definitive offers. This approach mitigates the risk of contractual breaches due to the limited availability of products.
For example, if a retailer advertises only five computers in a newspaper, treating the advertisement as an offer could lead to contractual liabilities with every respondent after the fifth, exceeding the available stock.
Therefore, an advertisement invites potential buyers to make their offers, leaving the seller with the discretion to accept or reject them based on availability and other factors.
The Nature of Shop Displays
Products displayed in a shop window or on store shelves constitute invitations to treat, not direct offers to sell. Taking an item to the cashier is the customer's offer to purchase. The transaction is completed, and the offer is accepted when the cashier processes the payment. This system ensures store owners retain control over sales, allowing them to manage situations like stock shortages or incorrect pricing.
Retail Display as Invitation to Treat
Items showcased in retail store windows or on shelves represent invitations to treat, not direct sales offers. The customer's action of taking the goods to the checkout constitutes an offer to buy. This offer is accepted when the retailer processes the sale at the till.
Price Lists as Preliminary Engagements
Price lists are generally regarded in the same vein as advertisements, serving as preliminary engagements rather than firm offers. If a price list were treated as an offer, the issuer would be bound to sell to anyone who accepts by placing an order, potentially exceeding their available stock.
Imagine a car accessories distributor issues a price catalogue for various Volkswagen parts. This catalogue is an invitation to treat, not a concrete offer. Should a garage place an order for Volkswagen brake pads based on this catalogue, their order constitutes an offer. The distributor can accept or decline this offer due to potential difficulties in sourcing sufficient brake pads.
Invitations to Tender. An invitation to tender calls interested entities to present bids detailing their readiness to undertake a specific task. It is not an offer, as agreeing to every tender would result in contractual breaches. The bids tendered are the offers.
A bookstore chain requires an upgraded point-of-sale system. It invites bids from software companies, where they detail the services and terms they can provide. This request is an invitation to treat, not an outright offer. The proposals made by the software companies are the offers, allowing the bookstore chain to select the most suitable one to accept.
Auction Procedures as Preliminary Invitations
In auctions, a catalogue serves not as a definitive offer but as an invitation to treat. This status permits the owner or auctioneer to retract items from the sale before the auction begins.
Similarly, when an auctioneer calls for bids, this is an invitation to treat. The auction attendees propose offers through their bids, which they can revoke before the auctioneer finalises the sale with the hammer's fall. The hammer's descent indicates the auctioneer's acceptance of the highest valid bid, assuming it meets any set reserve price.
Interpreting Price Quotations
Classifying a price quotation as either an offer or an invitation to treat depends significantly on the intentions of the involved parties, often discerned from their preceding interactions. In an academic or exam setting, it's less common to be tasked with making intricate judgments regarding the nature of price quotations.
The Special Case of Unilateral Contracts
Unilateral contracts represent a unique category where the usual rules are altered. Specifically, advertisements in these instances do constitute offers. A unilateral contract is established when the offeror pledges to perform a particular action if the offeree performs a specified task and the offeree completes that task. These contracts are termed 'unilateral' because only the offeror has an obligation (such as a promise of payment) when making the offer. The offeree can accept and become bound to the contract solely through performance. Often, these offers are made to the public, typically via advertisements, like promising a reward for specific actions. These advertisements are considered offers, as the offeror's intent to be legally bound is evident.
Consider a situation where a fitness company advertises a challenge: “Complete our 30-day fitness program without missing a day and receive £500.” The company also announces that it has set aside £20,000 to pay out these rewards, showing its commitment to the offer. A participant enrols in the program and diligently follows the regimen every day, but the company then refuses to pay the £500 upon completion.
In this case, a court will likely determine that the advertisement was an offer for a unilateral contract, which the participant accepted by fully adhering …
To continue reading paywall content, please
log in to verify your subscription status.
