On this page
Education Hub / SQE2 / Practice Areas/

Volenti non fit injuria

Topic

Volenti Non Fit Injuria in Tort Law

Volenti non fit injuria, a Latin phrase meaning "to a willing person, no harm is done," is a defence in tort law that absolves the defendant from liability if the claimant voluntarily accepted the risk of harm. This principle applies when the claimant knowingly and willingly undertakes an activity or situation fraught with obvious dangers. The defence is predicated on the idea that one cannot complain of harm they willingly consented to.

Elements of Volenti Non Fit Injuria

To successfully invoke this defence, the defendant must demonstrate two key elements:

  • ★ Knowledge of the Risk: The claimant must have been fully aware of the nature and extent of the risk involved in the activity or situation. Mere awareness of some risk is not enough; the claimant must understand the specific risk posed.
  • ★ Voluntary Acceptance: The claimant must have freely and voluntarily accepted the risk. This acceptance can be explicit, such as through a verbal agreement, or implied through conduct. The acceptance must be voluntary and not coerced or compelled by the circumstances.

Application of the Defence

The defence of volenti non fit injuria is commonly applied in scenarios involving high-risk activities or environments:

  • ★ High-Risk Sports and Activities: Participants in inherently dangerous sports or activities, such as skydiving or motor racing, are generally considered to have accepted the risks associated with these activities. Injuries sustained in such activities may not lead to successful claims if volenti is established.
  • ★ Employment and Dangerous Work: In certain occupations, employees may be deemed to have accepted certain risks associated with their work. However, this defence is not absolute in employment cases, particularly if the employer has failed to provide a safe working environment.
  • ★ Medical Procedures: Patients who consent to medical treatments or procedures generally accept the risks involved, provided they are adequately informed. This includes understanding potential complications or side effects.

Limitations of the Defence

There are significant limitations to the defence of volenti non fit injuria:

  • ★ Informed Consent: For the defence to apply, the claimant's consent must be fully informed. If the claimant was unaware of the specific risk or was misled about the nature of the risk, the defence may not succeed.★ Unavoidable Risks: The defence cannot apply where the claimant had no realistic option but to accept the risk, such as in situations of economic necessity or where refusal was not an option.
  • ★ Public Policy Considerations: Courts may refuse to apply the defence if it would be contrary to public policy, such as in cases involving gross negligence or where the defendant has a statutory duty to protect the claimant's safety.

Case Law

Morris v Murray (1990)

In this case, the claimant willingly went on a flight with a pilot who was visibly intoxicated. The court held that the claimant had voluntarily accepted the risk of injury by getting into the aircraft, applying the volenti defence and dismissing the claim.

Smith v Baker & Sons (1891)

Here, the court rejected the defence of volenti non fit injuria, holding that an employee's awareness of risk does not amount to voluntary acceptance, particularly when refusal might endanger employment. The employer's duty to provide a safe working environment could not be negated by the employee's knowledge of the danger.

Examples

Example 1 - Volenti in Sporting Events

Scenario:

A participant in a boxing match suffers injuries from the fight. Given the inherent risks of the sport, the defence of volenti non fit injuria may apply, as the participant accepted the risk of injury by agreeing to the match.

Example 2 - Volenti in Medical Procedures

Scenario:

A patient consents to a surgical procedure after being informed of the potential risks, including possible complications. If the surgery results in one of these known complications, the defence of volenti may prevent a successful claim for compensation, as the patient accepted the risks associated with the procedure.

Conclusion

Volenti non fit injuria is a vital defence in tort law that protects defendants from liability where the claimant has voluntarily accepted the risk of harm. This defence requires clear proof of the claimant's knowledge and voluntary acceptance of the risk. However, its application is limited by considerations of informed consent and public policy, ensuring that it is used justly and appropriately. Understanding the nuances of this defence is crucial for both defendants and claimants in cases involving accepted risks.

Defences Contributory negligence
27

53

SQE2

Specification

Explore