Right to have someone informed of arrest

Topic

Right to Have Someone Informed of Arrest

The right to have someone informed of an arrest is a fundamental legal entitlement for individuals who are detained by law enforcement authorities. This right ensures that a detainee's family, friends, or other interested parties are aware of their situation, thereby providing support and assistance during a critical time. It is a key safeguard within the criminal justice system, promoting transparency and accountability in the treatment of detainees.

In the United Kingdom, the right to have someone informed of an arrest is established under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) and its associated Codes of Practice. Specifically, Code C of PACE outlines the procedures and rights concerning detainees, including the right to notification of an arrest.

Case Law: R v Samuel [1988]

In *R v Samuel* [1988], the court highlighted the importance of ensuring that detainees' rights under PACE are respected, including the right to have someone informed of their arrest. The case underscored that any delay in exercising this right must be justified by compelling reasons, reflecting the necessity to uphold fundamental legal protections for detainees.

Entitlements Under the Right

Upon being detained, an individual is entitled to the following:

  • Notification of Arrest: Detainees have the right to have someone informed of their arrest and detention. This can include a family member, friend, or other nominated person. The police must inform the nominated person as soon as practicable after the detainee's request.
  • Right to Legal Representation: In addition to informing a third party, detainees are also entitled to seek legal advice and representation, which is a separate but related right under PACE.

Limitations and Exceptions

While the right to have someone informed of an arrest is generally upheld, there are certain circumstances where this right may be restricted or delayed:

  • Serious Crime Exception: If the police have reasonable grounds to believe that informing someone of the arrest would interfere with the investigation of a serious offence, or lead to the alerting of other suspects, they may delay this notification. Such delays are subject to strict oversight and must be justified.
  • Operational Reasons: In rare cases, operational needs may require a temporary delay in notification, particularly in situations involving multiple arrests or ongoing police operations.

Example: Delay Due to Risk of Alerting Other Suspects

Consider a situation where the police arrest a suspect involved in a large-scale drug operation. If the immediate notification of the arrest could potentially alert other suspects and jeopardize the investigation, the police may delay informing the detainee's nominated contact until it is safe to do so. This delay must be justified and documented, ensuring that it is only applied under exceptional circumstances.

Importance of the Right

The right to have someone informed of an arrest is crucial for several reasons:

  • Support and Assistance: Notifying a third party ensures that the detainee can receive emotional support and practical assistance, such as arranging legal representation or providing essential information.
  • Transparency and Accountability: This right promotes transparency in law enforcement procedures and helps prevent abuses of power, ensuring that detainees are treated fairly and their rights are respected.
  • Safeguarding Rights: Informing someone of the arrest can also act as a safeguard for the detainee's well-being, particularly in situations where they may be vulnerable or at risk.

Conclusion

The right to have someone informed of an arrest is a fundamental protection for individuals in police custody. It ensures that detainees are not isolated from external support and that their treatment is subject to public scrutiny. While there are limited circumstances in which this right can be restricted, such measures are carefully regulated to balance the needs of justice with the rights of the individual. Upholding this right is essential for maintaining trust in the criminal justice system and ensuring that the rights of detainees are fully protected.

SQE 2 Prep Course

Get Started