On this page
Education Hub / SQE2 / Practice Areas/

Pre-action and non-party disclosure

Topic

Pre-Action and Non-Party Disclosure

Pre-action and non-party disclosure are mechanisms in civil litigation that enable the early and comprehensive gathering of evidence. These procedures are governed by the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) and are designed to facilitate the resolution of disputes either before formal proceedings commence or involving individuals or entities not directly involved in the litigation. They play a crucial role in ensuring that all relevant evidence is available to the parties and the court, promoting a fair and efficient judicial process.

Pre-Action Disclosure

Pre-action disclosure allows a prospective claimant or defendant to obtain documents from the other party before formal proceedings are initiated. This can help in assessing the merits of a potential case, narrowing the issues, or even avoiding litigation altogether.

  • ★ Purpose: The primary purposes of pre-action disclosure are to clarify the issues, enable informed decision-making regarding the initiation of proceedings, and promote early settlement discussions.
  • ★ Criteria for Granting: A court may order pre-action disclosure if the following conditions are met:
    • ★ The respondent and the applicant are likely to be parties to subsequent proceedings.
    • ★ The documents sought would have been disclosed in the standard disclosure process if proceedings had already started.
    • ★ Disclosure before the commencement of proceedings is desirable to dispose fairly of the anticipated proceedings, assist the dispute to be resolved without proceedings, or save costs.
  • ★ Application Process: The applicant must file an application notice supported by evidence, explaining why the disclosure is necessary and identifying the documents or classes of documents sought. The application is served on the respondent, who has an opportunity to contest it.
  • ★ Outcome: If the court grants the order, it specifies the documents to be disclosed, the timeframe for disclosure, and any terms regarding the costs of disclosure.

Example - Pre-Action Disclosure

Scenario:

Jane believes she has a strong personal injury claim against her former employer, ABC Manufacturing, due to a workplace accident. However, Jane is unsure whether ABC Manufacturing complied with safety regulations and whether there is sufficient evidence to support her claim.

Pre-Action Disclosure Request:

Jane's solicitor files an application for pre-action disclosure, requesting safety inspection reports, maintenance logs, and internal communications about safety protocols from ABC Manufacturing. The application is supported by a witness statement from Jane, detailing her accident and the relevance of the requested documents.

Outcome:

The court considers the application and grants the order, determining that the requested documents are necessary for Jane to evaluate her potential claim. The court orders ABC Manufacturing to provide the specified documents, which reveal significant lapses in safety procedures. Based on this evidence, Jane decides to pursue her claim.

Non-Party Disclosure

Non-party disclosure involves obtaining documents from individuals or entities that are not parties to the litigation. This is particularly relevant when relevant evidence is held by third parties.

  • ★ Purpose: The purpose of non-party disclosure is to ensure that all relevant evidence is available to the court and the parties, even if it is in the possession of a third party. This can be crucial for a fair and comprehensive examination of the case.
  • ★ Criteria for Granting: To obtain an order for non-party disclosure, the applicant must show that:
    • ★ The documents sought are likely to support the applicant's case or adversely affect the case of another party.
    • ★ The disclosure is necessary to dispose fairly of the claim or to save costs.
    • ★ The non-party has the documents or control over them.
  • ★ Application Process: Similar to pre-action disclosure, the applicant must file an application notice supported by evidence, specifying the documents sought and their relevance. The application is served on the non-party, who may contest the application on grounds such as relevance, confidentiality, or burden of compliance.
  • ★ Outcome: The court may order the non-party to disclose specific documents, usually within a set timeframe. The order may include provisions for protecting confidential information or limiting the scope of disclosure to what is necessary for the case.

Example - Non-Party Disclosure

Scenario:

In a commercial dispute between two companies, TechCorp and SoftSolutions, over a breach of a software development contract, TechCorp alleges that SoftSolutions failed to deliver the software on time. However, a third-party consultancy, DataAnalysts, had been subcontracted by SoftSolutions to assist with project management.

Non-Party Disclosure Request:

TechCorp applies for non-party disclosure, seeking project reports and communications from DataAnalysts to understand the delays. The application is supported by an affidavit explaining the relevance of these documents to the dispute.

Outcome:

The court grants the order for non-party disclosure, finding that the documents held by DataAnalysts are likely to clarify the reasons for the delays. DataAnalysts is ordered to produce the documents, which reveal that SoftSolutions had repeatedly failed to meet project milestones, supporting TechCorp's claim.

Both pre-action and non-party disclosure involve careful consideration of various legal principles and protections:

  • ★ Proportionality: The court will weigh the benefit of obtaining the documents against the potential burden or cost to the disclosing party, ensuring that orders for disclosure are proportionate to the needs of the case.
  • ★ Confidentiality and Privilege: The court may impose limitations on disclosure to protect confidential or privileged information. This includes redacting sensitive information or restricting access to certain documents.
  • ★ Costs: The court may order that the party requesting disclosure bear the costs associated with producing the documents, especially in cases involving non-party disclosure, where the third party should not be unduly burdened.
  • ★ Privacy Concerns: The court must balance the need for disclosure with the privacy rights of individuals and the interests of non-parties, potentially limiting the scope or use of disclosed documents.

Conclusion

Pre-action and non-party disclosure are vital tools in civil litigation, ensuring that all relevant evidence is available to the parties and the court at an early stage. These procedures help clarify the issues in dispute, promote early resolution of conflicts, and prevent unnecessary litigation. While they provide valuable access to evidence, they must be balanced with considerations of proportionality, confidentiality, and the rights of non-parties. Properly managed, these disclosure mechanisms contribute significantly to the fairness and efficiency of the legal process.

Specific disclosure Electronic disclosure
27

53

SQE2

Specification

Explore