Capacity

Topic

Capacity in Contract Law

Capacity refers to the legal ability of a person or entity to enter into a contract. For a contract to be valid and enforceable, all parties involved must have the capacity to understand and commit to the agreement. Certain individuals and entities may lack capacity due to age, mental state, or other legal restrictions, making contracts voidable or unenforceable in some cases.

Minors

In most jurisdictions, individuals under the age of 18 are considered minors and generally lack the legal capacity to enter into binding contracts. However, there are exceptions where contracts with minors can be enforceable:

  • Necessaries: Minors can be held liable for contracts involving necessaries—goods or services essential for their livelihood and well-being, such as food, clothing, and shelter.
  • Beneficial Contracts of Service: Contracts that are beneficial to the minor, such as employment or apprenticeship agreements, may also be enforceable, provided they are in the minor's best interest.
  • Voidable Contracts: Other contracts made by minors are generally voidable at the minor's discretion, meaning they can choose to enforce or void the contract upon reaching the age of majority.

Mental Incapacity

Individuals who lack the mental capacity to understand the nature and consequences of a contract cannot be bound by its terms. This lack of capacity can arise from mental illness, cognitive impairments, or temporary conditions such as intoxication. Key points include:

  • Assessment of Capacity: Courts assess mental capacity at the time the contract was made. The individual must have been able to understand the contract's nature and effect.
  • Voidable Contracts: Contracts entered into by mentally incapacitated individuals are generally voidable. They can be ratified or voided upon regaining capacity or by their legal representative.
  • Necessaries Exception: Similar to minors, mentally incapacitated individuals can be held liable for contracts involving necessaries, ensuring they can access essential goods and services.

Intoxication

Intoxication can impair a person's capacity to contract. However, contracts entered into while intoxicated are not automatically void. The person must demonstrate that they were so intoxicated that they could not understand the nature and implications of the contract. Key considerations include:

  • Degree of Intoxication: The level of intoxication must be significant enough to affect the individual's understanding of the contract.
  • Ratification: A contract entered into while intoxicated can be ratified (confirmed) or voided once the person regains sobriety and full understanding.

Corporate Entities

Companies and other legal entities must have the capacity to enter into contracts, which is usually determined by their constitutional documents. Key aspects include:

  • Authority: Corporate representatives must have the authority to enter into contracts on behalf of the company. This authority may be explicit in the company's constitution or implied by the position held by the representative.
  • Ultra Vires Doctrine: Contracts entered into beyond the scope of a company's stated powers (ultra vires) may be void. However, modern company law often mitigates this doctrine, allowing companies to engage in a broad range of activities.

Examples

Example 1 - Contract with a Minor

Scenario:

A 17-year-old enters into a contract to purchase a luxury car. The minor later decides to void the contract, arguing they lacked capacity due to age. The contract is likely voidable at the minor's discretion.

Example 2 - Contract with a Mentally Incapacitated Person

Scenario:

An individual with a diagnosed mental illness enters into a contract while experiencing symptoms that impair their understanding. The contract may be voidable if it can be shown that they lacked the capacity to understand the agreement.

Conclusion

Capacity is a critical element in contract law, ensuring that all parties can understand and agree to the terms of a contract. Without capacity, agreements may be voidable or void, protecting those who lack the ability to make informed decisions. Recognizing the limitations on capacity, such as age, mental state, intoxication, or corporate authority, helps ensure that contracts are fair and legally enforceable. This principle upholds the integrity of contractual agreements by ensuring that all parties have the legal competence to engage in binding obligations.

SQE2

Specification

Explore